Defect documentation

Public-Benefits Application Defect Summary

This public artifact translates the three observed findings into concise QA records. Personal data and identifying source material are intentionally excluded.

← Back to the full case study

PB-001 — Uploaded evidence appears in multiple evidence rows

Area: Document upload and evidence mapping
Type: Data-mapping or presentation defect
Public reproduction status: Exact account-specific steps withheld; behavior was observed during an ordinary application workflow

Expected result
Each evidence row clearly displays the document associated with that record. A document is reused only through an intentional and visible user action.

Actual result
One uploaded document appeared in multiple evidence rows.

User impact
The user may be unable to confirm whether each record has the correct supporting evidence.

Risk
One document could appear to support multiple distinct records, creating ambiguity for both the user and a downstream reviewer.

Recommended verification

  • Confirm the document shown for every evidence row.
  • Replace one attachment and verify that no unrelated row changes.
  • Review the final submission summary for one-to-one mapping accuracy.
  • Verify intentional document reuse is clearly explained.

PB-002 — Extracted entity does not match the source document

Area: OCR and entity extraction
Type: Data-extraction defect
Public reproduction status: Source document withheld for privacy

Expected result
The extracted name and entity type match the source document, or the system requests confirmation when confidence is insufficient.

Actual result
An individual signer was classified as a different organizational entity.

User impact
The user may not know which extracted value is incorrect or how to correct it.

Risk
Inaccurate entity data may be carried into later review or submission steps.

Recommended verification

  • Test representative individual and organizational documents using fictional data.
  • Compare extracted names and entity types with the source text.
  • Verify correction controls are visible and usable.
  • Confirm corrected information persists through final review.

PB-003 — Validation warning conflicts with visible values

Area: Cross-field validation
Type: Validation or feedback defect
Public reproduction status: Exact application values withheld for privacy

Expected result
The warning identifies the affected fields, reflects their current values, explains the rule, and clears after a valid correction.

Actual result
The displayed warning did not correspond to the values visible to the user.

User impact
The user cannot confidently determine what must be changed.

Risk
The user may alter correct information, introduce new errors, or be unable to complete the workflow.

Recommended verification

  • Test values below, at, and above each relevant validation boundary.
  • Confirm the warning names the correct fields.
  • Correct the values and verify the warning clears.
  • Leave and return to the page to verify the correction persists.

Documentation boundaries

These records describe observable behavior and plausible risk. They do not claim access to internal implementation details or establish the defects’ root causes.


← Back to the full case study